Post

2 followers Follow
0
Avatar

Volume Calcs - error?

I have tested a few volume calcs on stockpiles and it seems that they are significantly larger than expected. (60m flight, 70% overlap, 10 m/s)
We have a coal stockpile which is approx 9,200m3 which MME calcs as 10,300m3, also a woodchip pile which is also about 10,000m3 and MME calc is 13,660m3. If I export the OBJ file into another program I can calc roughly the right volumes, so the model seems ok but the calcs overstated. I'll do a few more tests slower with more overlap and see if it changes the result.

https://www.mapsmadeeasy.com/maps/public/303896db96e54d6884a0eed28dafd883

Steven Thomson

Official comment

Avatar

All material above the base plane and inside the polygon is included. The base plane is defined by the lowest point inside the polygon.

Our volume calculations assume a that there is a flat base under the stockpile. If it is even slightly sloped the stockpile's volume will be overstated since it is including a lot of the ground under it.

Here is the text from the calculation popup:
Calculated Volume: 14,191.13 yd³
Void Volume: 25,192.96 yd³
Base Plane: 19.69 ft
Maximum Height: 51.74 ft
Area of Measurement: 3696.47 yd²
Height Samples Used: 298,571
Sample Size: 4 in x 4 in

In this case, the base plane was set at 19.69 ft. This value occurred at one end and the other end is 22.1 ft. Assuming it is a rectangle, which it clearly isn't, and that the slope was consistent from one end to the other, you could multiply the Area of Measurement 3696 yd² by the difference the base heights of .8 yd and divide by 2. This gives a slope contribution to the volume of 1478 yd³.

We will look at accounting for this in the future.

Tudor
Comment actions Permalink

Please sign in to leave a comment.

1 comment